Thursday, February 14, 2013

Jo Shelby on "Bleeding Kansas"


Joseph "Jo" O. Shelby was born in Lexington, Kentucky, in 1830, and was educated at Transylvania University. As a young man he ran a hemp rope manufactory and moved to Missouri in 1852. After the Kansas-Nebraska Act passed two years later, Shelby found himself caught up in the "Bleeding Kansas" battles.

As an old man he related his experience in those dire days of discord. Giving his story to a Kansas historian he related:

"I was in Kansas at the head of an armed force about that time. I went there to kill Free State men. I did kill them. I am now ashamed of myself for having done so, but then times were different from what they are now, and that is what I went there for. We Missourians all went there for that purpose if it should be found necessary to carry out our designs. I had no business there. No Missourian had any business there with arms in his hands. The policy that sent us there was damnable and the trouble we started there on the border bore fruit for ten years. I ought to have been shot there and John Brown was the only man who knew it and would have done it. I say John Brown was right. He did in his country what I would have done in mine in like circumstances. Those were the days when slavery was in the balance and the violence engendered made men irresponsible. I now see I was so myself."

Shelby fought for the Confederacy in the Civil War, doing battle in the Trans-Mississippi theater, rising in rank from captain to general. Instead of surrendering at the end of the war, Shelby took his force to Mexico, where he stayed until 1867. Upon returning to Missouri he took up farming again and died in 1897.

Shelby quote from General Jo Shelby: Undefeated Rebel by Daniel O'Flaherty, page 44.

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

"Old Rough and Ready"


Zachary Taylor, Mexican War hero and 12th president of the United States, is shown in this highly romantic Whig campaign poster for the 1848 election in which he defeated Democrat Lewis Cass of Michigan.

"Old Rough and Ready," gentleman politician, is shown here surrounded by his Mexican War victories festooned on banners encircling the pillars supporting "justice" and "peace." A sunburst with descending dove is shown above him and under United States flags. Taylor is mounted on his favorite horse "Old Whitey" and at the steed's feet is a fascine bundle, wrapped and labeled "Union."

Born in Virginia in 1784, but coming to Kentucky with his family as an infant, Taylor joined the army as a young man and fought in the War of 1812 and Seminole War.  His great fame was won in Mexico though battles such as Palo Alto, Resaca de la Palma, Monterrey, and Buena Vista.

The quintessential Whig, Henry Clay, did not receive the party's nomination in 1848 as he had lost the 1844 election to Democrat James K. Polk and was viewed as unable to attain the presidency after other several past failed attempts.

Taylor, like Whig William Henry Harrison in 1840, would not survive his term as president. He died on July 9, 1850. Vice President Millard Fillmore followed after Taylor's death and was then defeated in 1852 by Vermont Democrat Franklin Pierce.

Image courtesy of the Library of Congress.

Monday, February 11, 2013

A Mexican War Image


The soldier pictured above has what might be one of the most unique nineteenth century first names I have come across - and I have seen some strange ones. 

According to information I was able to find online, Bazaleel Wells Armstrong was born in 1823 in Ohio and served as was a lieutenant in 2nd Regiment Dragoons in the Mexican War. Apparently his father was General John Armstrong and his mother was Isabella McKaig Armstrong. It also appears that Armstrong survived combat, but according to a printed notice in the Lima [Ohio] Argus he died in New Lisbon, Ohio, on February 17, 1849, at 26 years old. 

Was his death due to wounds received in the war? Or, was it from a tropical disease he contracted in Mexico? Did he commit suicide, or was he murdered? Was he in an accident?

Mexican War photographs like this are rather rare as the science of making daguerreotype images was only about a decade old when the war broke out.  

Image courtesy of the National Archives.

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Just Finished Reading - Apostles of Equality

I was thrilled to see a book finally come out that covered the remarkable career of James G. Birney. Birney's evolution from slaveholder to colonization proponent to emancipationist to abolitionist is one of the amazing stories of the nineteenth century and one that has been overlooked for too long in scholarship.

D. Laurence Rogers, a journalist and Michigan historian, tells Birney's biography - and with it America's story.  He shows that both transformed from being proslavery to opposing the institution. As we all know, that evolution was one that was full of obstacles and pitfalls; much like Birney's life.

Birney was born in Danville, Kentucky, in 1792 and grew up in slaveholding household. His father owned a profitable hemp plantation that provided Birney the opportunity to have an excellent education at Transylvania University and later Princeton.

After Princeton, Birney returned to Danville and practiced law, then like so many others of that era, went into politics. He landed a seat in the Kentucky legislature at 24. In 1818 though he moved his family to a cotton plantation in Madison County, Alabama. Birney's career as planter was short lived and he soon went back to life as an attorney, practicing in Huntsville, Alabama, where he was also elected mayor, and served the Alabama legislature.

While in Alabama, Birney became convinced that colonization was the best alternative to dealing with the growing slavery controversy that was troubling the country. Birney decided to move back to Danville in 1832. Back in Kentucky he transformed from colonizationist to gradual emancipationist. Still unconvinced with the progress of emancipation he freed his remaining slaves in 1834 and declared himself an abolitionist. Efforts to start an antislavery newspaper in Kentucky in 1835 was thwarted though and Birney moved Cincinnati, Ohio. He moved yet again, this time to New York in 1837 to work for the American Antislavery Society.

In 1840 Birney ran for president on the antislavery Liberty Party ballot. He ran again in 1844 and has gone down in history as costing Henry Clay the vital votes he needed, and thus lost to James K. Polk. Birney, seemingly ever on the move, transplanted again in 1847 to Michigan. He remained in Michigan until 1855 when he moved to New Jersey where he died in 1857.

Rogers contends, and I agree, that Birney's politics and his run for president as Liberty Party candidate paved the way for the later Free Soil Party. And the Free Soil Party saw the later emergence of the Republican Party, which originated in 1854 as party against slavery's expansion.

While I truly enjoyed reading Apostles of Equality I was discouraged to find so many factual errors included throughout the book. Early (page 33) Rogers seemed to get confused about Humphrey Marshall (1760-1841) who fought a duel with Henry Clay in 1809 with Marshall's grandson, also Humphrey (1812-1872), who became a Confederate general in the Civil War. How Rogers could have thought that someone old enough to fight a duel in 1809 could have still fought 50 years later in the Civil War is difficult for me to understand.  And that certainly was not the only error. On page 39 he states that the Liberator newspaper began publishing in 1830, William Lloyd Garrison's paper actually started the next year, 1831. On the same page he claims that the Denmark Vesey conspiracy happened in 1821, it was 1822.  On page 179 he claims that John Wilkes Booth was captured and killed in Maryland, but that actually happened in Caroline County, Virginia. On page 189, Rogers states that John Brown dedicated himself to antislavery at the funeral of Elijah Lovejoy in 1836.  Lovejoy was actually killed in 1837 and while John Brown did dedicate himself to the elimination of slavery upon the occasion of Lovejoy's death, Brown was not in attendance at Lovejoy's actual funeral. On page 199 the author claimed that Preston Brooks, the famous caner of Charles Sumner hailed from Georgia; he was from South Carolina. All of these mistakes are fairly minor and probably would be overlooked by most readers, but to those of us who know better these errors make one wonder if there are others that I missed and thus causes the book to lose some credibility in my eyes.

Apostles of Equality doesn't end with James G. Birney's life. Thankfully Rogers also covers the careers of Birney's sons, four of which (and a grandson) served in the Union army. Two of his sons carried on their father's abolitionist mission by commanding United States Colored Troops.

I would rate Apostles of Equality higher if those errors I mentioned above had been caught by proofreaders or the publishing editor.  However, it is still an enjoyable book on a too-long ignored personality that needed covered. On a scale of 1 to 5, I give it a 4.

Saturday, February 9, 2013

Old '76 and Young '48


A few posts ago I shared Richard Caton Woodville's News from Mexico. Above is Woodville's Old '76 and Young '48, which depicts a scene from the same era, albeit in a more intimate atmosphere.

Woodville chose a setting that is likely in a Southern household parlor. "Young '48" tells about his adventures in the war and seemingly motions toward the Revolutionary War portrait on the wall with the right arm while his left arm is in a sling, presumably a wound from the Mexican War. The soldier's military cap, gauntlets and sword are on the carpeted floor behind him. "Old '76", probably Young '48's grandfather, listens to the young man tell his tale and appears to be lost in thought, possibly remembering his combat experiences in the Revolutionary War.  Behind the old man and up high is bust of George Washington and above the fireplace mantle is a portrait of John Trumbull's Signing of the Declaration of Independence.

All of the individuals - possibly Young 48's mother, father, and sister - appear to be concentrating on the young man's words, which seem to be serious. At the door appears to be a group of house slaves intent on hearing what is being told, too.  The family dog, in the foreground, appears to be as attentive as the depicted humans.

Woodville's short life appears to be - like the war that was the basis of these paintings - a tragedy. Born in 1825 to a prominent Baltimore, Maryland family, he died in London at age 30 from a morphine overdose.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Rial, a Slave Belonging to W.B. Galaway

Sunday night while watching the Super Bowl I got bored when the Superdome lights went out, so I started searching through some Kentucky Civil War era newspapers.

In the February 9, 1864 issue of the Frankfort Daily Commonwealth I ran across a classified advertisement that caught my attention. It stated:

"Proclamation by the Governor, $100 Reward
Commonwealth of Kentucky
Executive Department

Whereas it has been made known to me that RIAL, a slave belonging to W. B. Galaway, of Scott County, did in the - day of 186-, murder Jeremiah Martin, of said county, and is now going at large.

Now, therefore I, Thos. E. Bramlette, Governor of the Commonwealth aforesaid, do hereby offer a reward of ONE HUNDRED DOLLARS, for the apprehension of said Rial, property of said W. B. Galaway, and his delivery to the jailer of Scott County, within one year from the date hereof:

In testimony Whereof, I have hereon to set my hand, and caused the seal to be affixed. Done at Frankfort, this 27th day of Jan. A.D. 1864 and in the 72 year of the Commonwealth.
By the Governor Tho. E. Bramlette
E.L. VanWinkle, Secretary of State
Jas. R. Page, Assistant Secretary

Description - The Rial is about 45 years old. 5 feet 8 inches high, rather small, black, with the front lower fore tooth out, speaks slow and low, and has humble appearance."

Naturally, curiosity got the best of me, so I located some information on W.B. Galloway (not Galaway). In the 1850 census he is listed as the owner of 12 slaves (8 males and 4 females, all between the ages of 50 and 1 year old). In the 1860 census Galloway owned 9 slaves (5 females and 4 males, between the ages of 50 and 11). Also in 1860 he had $26,000 in real estate and $11,600 in personal property, most of which would have been the 9 slaves.  He was a 37 year old bachelor farmer and 6 people lived in his household.  Apparently he boarded his two aunts Miriam and Thircissmus McCalla, 50 and 45 respectively.  In the household too was Margaret Davis, white and 22 years old (who in the 1870 census was still in the household and listed as servant).  Included too were S. Q. Adams, a 29 year old physician, and J. W. Bower, a 22 year old merchant.

I also found a Civil War Draft Registrations record for 1863-1865 where Galloway was listed as a 40 year old single farmer and had a note, "Hand Crippled."

I was unable to find any 1860 census record information for the murdered Jeremiah Martin in Scott County, which made me wonder if Jeremiah Martin was a slave too, thus he would not have appeared in the census. But, if he was a slave wouldn't the notice had indicated such? I'm not sure.

Anyway, my curiosity has not been sated. In fact I am even more curious to find out what happened to Rial (was he caught? was there a trial? was he punished or executed? or did he continue to "go at large"?). And who this Jeremiah Martin? I suppose a trip over to neighboring Scott County is in order in the near future.

Governor Thomas E. Bramlette image courtesy of the Kentucky Historical Society

Monday, February 4, 2013

Just Finished Reading - The House on Diamond Hill

Too often overlooked in Southern history is the fact that some American Indians owned slaves. A few elites, like the focus of The House on Diamond Hill: A Cherokee Plantation Story, the Vann family, owned large numbers of enslaved workers and to a large degree mirrored white Southern antebellum plantation life.

James Vann, the son of a white trader father and Cherokee mother inherited a great deal of wealth and capitalized on a number of opportunities that helped increase his fortune in land and slaves at the turn of the nineteenth century. Vann lived a profligate lifestyle at Diamond Hill. He abused his wives, drank to excess, and was even accursed by his neighbors of being mentally imbalanced. Vann was gunned down in 1809 by an unknown assailant as he drank at a local tavern. Having many enemies, his killer was never identified.

James Vann's son Joseph inherited much of Diamond Hill and its slave workforce. Joseph turned out to be much more responsible than his father and kept the plantation profitable. In the early 1820s, Joseph Vann had a beautiful brick Federal-style house built that showed off his wealth and high standing in the Cherokee nation. Unfortunately, Joseph Vann's enjoyment of the house would be short lived. He and other Cherokees were removed from Georgia and settled in what would become Oklahoma. Vann, however, was much better off than the majority of his fellow Cheokees. His wealth insulated him from the harsh realities of relocation that the "Trail of Tears" afforded to others. Vann became one of the richest Cherokees in Oklahoma, taking his slaves with him and purchasing a steamboat named the Lucy Walker. Vann's destiny was tied to the Lucy Walker more than he knew when he made the purchase. He and an number of the boat's passengers died in a boiler explosion on the Ohio River near New Albany, Indiana in 1844.

While the Vann family stories are certainly interesting  much of the book focuses on the enslaved workers at Diamond Hill, especially the women. Thanks to the Moravian mission, Springplace, and the copious notes that they kept on their Vann neighbors, we have an idea of what life was like on this elite Cheorkee plantation. As author Tiya Miles explains, "Diamond Hill was a place where the slave population was large enough to sustain a black community and where the dominant Indian culture held features in common with African societies. Enslaved people in this location were therefore able to develop a unique black lifeworld rooted in memories of Africa, adapted to a new indigenous American context, and insulated from the intense acculturative pressures of the white slaveholding South." Indeed, many of the slaves at Diamond Hill spoke Cherokee and English, and some - who had interaction with the Moravians - even spoke bits of German. It was truly a multicultural world away tucked in the Cherokee nation.

In The House on Diamond Hill Miles also provides a history of efforts of the area's residents to preserve and interpret the Chief Vann House, which is now administered by the state of Georgia. The story of Diamond Hill for too long only covered the Cherokee and Moravian story, but now the full history of this unique Southern plantation is told by incorporating the African American and Afro-Cherokee slaves that provided the Vanns with much of their wealth and comfort.

On a scale of 1 to 5, I give The House on Diamond Hill a 4.75. I think anyone interested in Southern history will enjoy this fantastic book and its unique topic.

Sunday, February 3, 2013

Midway's McKee Monument


As you might have noticed by some of my recent posts, I have developed somewhat of an interest in Kentucky's role in the Mexican-American War. I first noticed the Col. William McKee monument in Midway, Kentucky last summer when I took some photos of the Martyr's Monument. I didn't pay much attention to the McKee monument then other than noting it was placed in honor of a Mexican War veteran. 

Today, suffering somewhat from cabin fever, I took the short drive over to Midway and took some snapshots of the monument to share here.

If you have never been to Midway, you are missing out on a true gem.  Midway is a charming little Woodford County town midway (thus the name) between Lexington and Frankfort on the line of the Lexington and Ohio railroad. As the railroad neared completed in the 1830 the town developed.


The McKee monument was erected in 1847 to honor William Robertson McKee, colonel of the 2nd Kentucky Volunteers (the regiment's lieutenant colonel was Henry Clay, Jr.). Both Clay and McKee were killed at the Battle of Buena Vista on February 23, 1847. Engraved on one side of the monument is the following very mid-nineteenth century sentiment:

"This humble monument is graciously erected by the citizens of Midway and vicinity as an abiding memorial of their admiration of the pure and noble character and useful service, civil and military, of the accomplished gallant and much lamented COL. WILLm R. McKEE who in triumphantly defending his country's flag at the head of the immortal 2nd REGIMENT of KENTUCKY VOLUNTEERS fell gloriously in the last moment of the memorable battle of BUENA VISTA in which that regiment with its able and heroic leader, by unsurpassed skill and persevering valor, in a bloody conflict of an entire day, emblazoned the exalted character of their beloved Commonwealth, and achieved for themselves DEATHLESS HONOR AND RENOWN.  


William Robertson McKee graduated from the United States Military Academy (West Point) in the class of 1829, which also featured such notables as Robert E. Lee and Joseph E. Johnston.  His father Samuel McKee (1774-1826) was a Kentucky politician that served in both the state and United States House of Representatives. McKee was buried along with Henry Clay, Jr. in the Frankfort Cemetery. Both soldiers rest below the Kentucky Military Monument, which was authorized in 1848 by the state legislature and completed in 1850.


Also engraved on the monument is an oval that contains the symbol of the Union; a bald eagle holding arrows and an olive branch, with the motto E PLURIBUS UNUM - out of many one. Also included in the engraving is a plow (peace), a cannon (war), and American flag (Union).

Saturday, February 2, 2013

The Death of Henry Clay, Jr. in Mexico


Although his father, Henry Clay - the Great Compromiser - vehemently opposed the United States' military action with Mexico, Henry Clay Junior proudly enlisted and served as Lieutenant Colonel in the 2nd Kentucky Infantry.

Junior, the most promising of Clay's sons to attempt to follow in the patriarch's huge shoes, graduated second in his West Point class in the early 1830s.  After his education he practiced law and served a term in the Kentucky House of Representatives. Surely, the thought of gaining some glory and notoriety in the war must have enter the mind of Clay the younger who had once written in his diary: "How difficult it is for a young tree to grow in the shade of an aged oak."

Junior's Mexican War experience got off to fits and starts. He lost much of his early war fever when he was injured after a fall from his horse. Clay was also disillusioned with his overbearing superiors. But then in what was arguably one of the most important battles of the war, Buena Vista, on February 23, 1847, Junior was wounded in the left thigh (pictured above). He requested that his men leave him and fall back to regroup. As the wounded Clay watched his men leave he was pierced multiple times by the feared Mexican lancers. Before sending his men away, Clay entrusted to a subordinate officer a set of pistols that his father had provided him and requested they be brought back to his father in Kentucky.  

Interestingly, Clay's body was retrieved by two Kentucky slaves that worked as manservants for the 2nd Kentucky. As historian Amy Greenberg relates in her recently published A Wicked War, "Joel, an enslaved body servant and son of a prominent Lexington barber well known to the Clay family, was himself injured in the process."

Not only did the pistols come back to Kentucky, the body of Henry Clay Jr., too, was returned to his native state and was eventually placed in the Frankfort Cemetery.

Thursday, January 31, 2013

Just Finished Reading - Weirding the War

I think most of us are somewhat suckers for the bizarre. Tell me honestly that you don't sometimes wonder if there really are Sasquatches when you flip through the channels and land on "Finding Bigfoot." Or, that there might just be something to some of those far-fetched conspiracy theories. OK, "Ancient Aliens" may be going too far. But still, we like weird. What else can explain the popularity of a holiday like Halloween.

If you sometimes like to think about the Civil War's more unusual topics - those that just a little outside of the box - then Weirding the War: Stories from the Civil War's Ragged Edges may just be your fix.

As editor Stephen Berry states "Here then is not the grandness of the Civil War but its more than occasional littleness. Here are those who profited by the war and those who lost by it - and not lost all save honor, but lost that too. Here are the cowards, the coxcombs, and the belles, the deserters and the scavengers who hung back and survived, even thrived. Here are those who did not see a redemptive conflict or a manly test by a fool's errand and a fool's grave that better belonged to somebody else. Here are those who did worse than nothing, who were animated not even by misbegotten principles. Here are those who saw and lived the reality of the war but decided it would be better lived down, misremembered, repackaged for public consumption. Here, in short, is war."

Included in Weirding the War rare 18 essays that are divided into six parts, with naturally 3 essays each. Part 1, "Death Becomes Us: The Civil War and the Appetite for Destruction" is sometimes ghoulish but even  more intriguing. Part 2, "Hell's Bells: New Looks Civil War Women" is seductive, flirtatious, and economically independent. Part 3, "Inside the Civil War Body" is tortuous, hungry and a coroner. Part 4, "Tortuous Road to Freedom" was probably my favorite group of essays. It included articles on the refugees at Camp Nelson, Kentucky, KKK connections with the age old tradition of horsemanship ring tournaments, and lastly but very interestingly, a look at desertion and community among USCT units. Part 5, "Honor is a Gift a Man Gives Himself - And Men Can Be Very Generous," is cowardly yet faithful, fictitious, and talkative. Part 6, "Picking Up the Pieces" is dismembered, mental, and vindictive.  Hopefully those tidbits pique your interest enough to give this book a look.

Berry's "Introduction" and essay, "The Historian as Death Investigator" are real standout gems, but the other essays do not disappoint either. I don't think you will be disappointed with Weirding the War. In fact, I think you will find the "strangeness" of the essays rather refreshing. On a scale of 1 to 5, I give this unique and "weird" book a 5.

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Governor Owsley's Mexican War Proclamation


As a Whig, Kentucky Governor William Owsley was personally opposed to the war with Mexico, but on May 17, 1846 he issued a stirring proclamation to the people of Kentucky.

"Whereas, from information this day informally received at this department, it is believed that the Congress of the United States has, upon the recommendation of the President [James K. Polk], passed as an act authorizing the receiving into the service of the United States fifty thousand volunteers to aid the Army of Occupation now on the Rio Grande, or to give such other service as may be required for the defense of our Southern frontier and the maintenance of the national interests and honor: and whereas, this department had also received a communication form the commander of the Western division of the army, giving notice of an application having been made to the President for volunteers from Kentucky: and whereas, recent intelligence for the Army of Occupation leaves no doubt that hostilities have been actually commenced.

Now, therefore, mindful of the high renown that Kentucky had acquired patriotism and gallantry, and being unwilling at a crisis like this, that our noble state should suffer herself to be surpassed in devotion to the common cause of our country, I, William Owsley, governor of the commonwealth of Kentucky, do issue this my proclamation, appealing to pride, the patriotism, and the chivalry of Kentuckians, hereby urging them to form themselves into volunteer companies, and report the fact of their organization to this department forthwith, signifying to them my firm conviction that orders will in a few days be received from the President of the United States, empowering and directing me to cause them to be immediately mustered into the service of the United States, at some point which will be designated."

Answering the governor's call Kentucky raised far more troops than were needed. The federal government only asked for two regiments of infantry and one of cavalry, but the over 100 companies volunteered. The governor had to refuse the service of 75 of the companies. Only 2,400 troops were asked of the Bluegrass state, but about 13,000 came out to find adventure and attempt to preserve the state's honor it felt it had earned fighting Indians in the state's early history and in the War of 1812. 4,694 Kentuckians eventually made it south of the border.

Like the Civil War, disease claimed far more lives of Mexican War soldiers than combat. 622 Kentuckians died from various ailments in Mexico, while only 71 died from actual fighting.

Image courtesy of the Kentucky Historical Society

Friday, January 25, 2013

War News From Mexico


The below information is from the Smithsonian Institution:

Between 1830 and the Civil War, there was a flourish of American “genre paintings,” depictions of everyday life and ordinary people. Many of these works show citizens engaging in local politics or reacting to news of national events. Richard Caton Woodville’s War News from Mexico, first exhibited in 1848, was perhaps the most popular of the political paintings. This lithograph was one of some 14,000 prints sold.

The various and ambiguous reactions of the characters at Woodville’s “American Hotel” are suggestive of national opinions on the Mexican War. The overture to the war was the annexation of Texas in 1845, which met with opposition in the North. James Russell Lowell wrote that the South saw in Texas “bigger pens to cram slaves in.” The most famous protester was Henry David Thoreau, who went to jail in Massachusetts for refusing to pay taxes. The Whig opposition in Congress denounced “Mr. Polk’s war,” but went along with appropriations for military campaigns deep into Mexico.

The Republic of Texas had claimed the Rio Grande as its southern and western border. Mexico insisted that the border was the Nueces River, farther to the north and east (though it never officially recognized the independence of Texas). President James K. Polk sent troops into the disputed area in January 1846. Four months later, the Mexican army moved in and attacked a unit of U.S. soldiers. In Polk’s interpretation, Mexico had “shed American blood upon American soil.” Congress declared war on May 13, 1846.

The Mexican War was a decisive victory for the U.S., however indecisively the country supported it. In the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, signed in February 1848, Mexico turned over more than 500,000 square miles of its territory, including California and nearly all of what is now the American Southwest.

These gains seemed a fulfillment of “Manifest Destiny,” an idea put forth by New York editor John L. O’Sullivan. On the occasion of the annexation of Texas, O’Sullivan wrote that the United States had a self-evident right “to overspread the continent allotted by Providence for the free development of our yearly multiplying millions.” He looked forward to the seizure of California from Mexico as an inevitability: “Already the advance guard of the irresistible army of Anglo-Saxon emigration has begun to pour down upon [California], armed with the plough and the rifle, and marking its trail with schools and colleges, courts and representative halls, mills and meeting-houses.” 


Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Just Finished Reading - Kentucke's Frontiers

I have been wanting to brush up on my knowledge of early Kentucky history for quite some time now. It was always my father's favorite era, but I seemed to gravitate more toward the mid-nineteenth century.  However, when I went searching for recent scholarship I was somewhat disappointed to find that there has not been much published in the past ten years.

A recent book that did catch my eye was Kentucke's Frontiers (winner of the 2011 Kentucky Governor's Award), by North Carolina State University professor Craig Thompson Friend.

In Kentucke's Frontiers, Friend provides a thorough account of Kentucky's early history from its first explorers up to the early nineteenth century. In doing so he looks closely at the terror that was experienced by those early explorers and settlers and how their fears of Indian raids and the frontier's wild beasts translated into culture of hero worship that ultimately limited egalitarian possibilities for white women and African Americans. As Friend explains, "Like poorer white men, blacks and white women watched as opportunities that had existed for them in Kentucke withered as Kentucky took shape. . . . During the 1770s and 1780s some members of both groups tasted social, economic, and religious independence. In the 1790s, however, both blacks and white women faced greater legal restrictions on their social and economic activities."

Friend contends that in the 1770s and 1780s "Slaves gained mobility and a sense of autonomy through the illegal but unregulated practice of hiring out. . . . White women too, both as widows and as wives acting in their husbands' absences, enjoyed some economic independence, exerting authority over salt manufactories, artisan shops, slaves and farms."

As you might have noticed in the last couple of paragraphs, Friend divides the commonwealth's early history (roughly 1750 to 1820) by labeling the earliest years as Kentucke, as it was often spelled by those white hunters and explorers, and the later period - after statehood was granted in 1792 - as the modern spelling Kentucky.

The hero worship that resulted from terroristic Indians raids (contrary to period accounts only men supposedly could defend hearth and home) developed into community reinforced organizations (county courts, state legislature, and churches) and a common culture that resulted in a white patriarchy and transformed the Bluegrass State into an Old South state in the antebellum years. However, as Friend contends and I certainly would agree, the terror did not stop with the disappearance of Indians. Black African American slaves took the red Indians' place. Friend states, "Unlike Native Americans, few blacks had the resources or freedom to actually pose threats. But African Americans were ubiquitous in Kentucky, and their omnipresence unsettled whites. As whites employed terror against slaves and free blacks to keep a real threat from manifesting, they too became dangerous Others in the eyes of their black neighbors."  My personal research on Kentuckians' reactions to John Brown's raid vividly supports this particular argument.

I enjoyed reading Kentucke's Frontiers and thinking about the unique arguments that Friend poses. Hopefully more scholars will continue to reexamine Kentucky's early years, how the state's history has been told, and what we can learn from those narratives. On a scale of 1 to 5, I give Kentucke's Frontiers a 4.75.

Monday, January 21, 2013

Tending to Others' Children

Yesterday I posted about the book, On Slavery's Border by Diane Mutti Burke. The cover of the book showed an enslaved African American woman holding a white child. Inside the book it explains that the woman was named Louisa and the child was Harry E. Hayward. It was estimated that the picture was taken in 1858. That date was probably chosen as Louisa was purchased that year by George A. Hayward, "a St. Louis businessman  . . perhaps for the purpose of assisting his wife, Ellen, in caring for their young son." The caption in the book also explains that while the photograph "suggests the intimate relations that existed between slaveholding family members and their slaves. . .it also suggests their complex nature."

The image struck the same as was as it was described in the caption. Many times slaves, and after emancipation, freedwomen servants, were viewed as part of the Southern family household. However, racial undertones were in most cases probably not far from the surface, and certainly the white/black power dynamic was always understood and upheld.

In my various searches for historic images I often run across similar photographs. Some are from the antebellum and Civil War years, while others are from Reconstruction  and beyond - as the custom of black child caregivers lasted well into the twentieth century - and not only in the South, but also in the North. Some of these images are shared here. Most do not have identifications, and if they do, it is usually the white child rather than the African American woman who is identified. 


Unidentified and undated African American woman and white child. 


Only the white child, Ada Peters Brown, is identified in this image. The smiling African American woman is not named.


This photograph is identified as Mary Allen Watson, and dated as June 15, 1866, but it is not known if Mary Allen Watson is the child or woman. Most likely it was the child that was noted.


Unidentified African American woman with two white children.


Kate Marschall English (infant) and Violet (nurse).

Historian Elizabeth Fox-Genovese in her book Within the Plantation Household: Black and White Women of the Old South sums up the complicated nature of slaveholding women and the bondswomen in their homes: "The personal relations between house slaves and the white family could range from love to hatred, but whatever their emotional quality, they were more likely than not to include a high level of intimacy. Mistresses whipped slave women with whom they might have shared beds, whose children they might have delivered  or who might have delivered theirs, whose children they might have suckled and who frequently suckled theirs."

Top four images courtesy of the Library of Congress. Bottom image courtesy of the Kentucky Historical Society.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Just Finished Reading - On Slavery's Border

I read On Slavery's Borders: Missouri's Small-Slaveholding Households, 1815-1865, by Diane Mutti Burke, about a year and half ago, but I reread it recently for a book discussion group at work. I'm glad I found the time to read it again, because I had the opportunity to refresh some of the information that I had overlooked or not remembered from the first reading.

As the subtitle indicates, much of On Slavery's Border examines the relations between black slaves and their white master families. Here, Burke paints a picture of uniqueness in Missouri. Unlike the large-slaveholding plantations in states such as Alabama, Mississippi, and Louisiana, where slaves and masters often experienced a more disjointed relationship, Missouri's slave system was different. Here slaveholders often lived and worked side by side with their bondsmen.

As Burke explains "On Slavery's Border uses a bottom-up approach to examine how the experience of slavery and slaveholding was influenced by both the size of slaveholding and geography. In a place such as Missouri  slavery developed into a region of small slaveholdings precisely because of it geographic location; both climate and proximity to free states discouraged the migration of planters and conversely encouraged the migration of slaveholders of smaller means. Small slaveholders were marginalized in much of the South, but in Missouri they dominated, creating a slavery culture that differed socially, politically, and economically from that of plantation regions.

Burke is clear to point out that this more close-style of slaveholding did not necessarily mean a more benevolent of benign form of slavery, quite the contrary. Being in such close contact often led to frayed nerves and offended feelings on both parts, which in turn led to violent outbursts.

One thing that caught my attention in my second reading was that in the 1850 and 1850 censuses the census takers were instructed to note the locations where slaves were living, not necessarily who owned them. The object of the census, the instructions said, was to determine the number of slaves, not the number of masters. In other words, if a slave or two was being rented by a man, those slaves would be listed under the name of that renter, not the actual owner's name. In upper-South states slave hiring out was a common practice for owners that had surplus laborers but who did not want to sell his/her personal property. Therefore, it seems to me that this fact makes it difficult for historians to tell if small slaveholders were actually owners or possibly renters; especially since the census was usually taken in the summer and fall, when, of course, labor was most needed and likely to be rented.

Slave renting comes in for a good deal of discussion in the work, and Burke explains its wide prevalence  "Those who owned no slaves fulfilled more than their labor need through the hiring of slaves; they also purchased the social and psychological rewards of mastery - in many cases on the cheap. As Jonathan Martin has argued, 'Entree into the slaveholding ranks brought both cultural and economic rewards; in the South, the luxury of ordering slaves about was a way to enhance both one's social standing and one's production for the market.'"

Slave hiring/renting often was done to help white farm women. As Burke states "Most rural American women labored at a tremendous amount of housework, and often barnyard word and fieldwork as well. What set slaveholding women apart from other white women was their ability to free themselves from fieldwork and the most physically demanding and undesirable of domestic tasks precisely because they owned slave women to whom the could assign this grueling labor. The work of slaveholding women, or rather those tasks never performed by them, was essential in defining what it meant to be a lady in southern society."

Burke takes much of her primary source evidence on white small slaveholders from the collections of a number of family collections. Her evidence for enslaved individuals often comes from the WPA Slave Narratives and individuals slave narratives such as William Wells Brown and Henry Clay Bruce. The information these records provide are sometimes both informative and flawed as Burke points out. For example, the WPA narratives were taken during the Great Depression when life under segregation, especially in the Southern states, was particularly difficult causing these elderly former slaves to possibly misremember how trying slave days were. Also, their memories - due to so much time passing since the events they described - must make one cautious of what was said to the interviewers.

As I reread On Slavery's Border I kept saying to myself, "that sounds like Kentucky's experience." And, that certainly makes sense since many of Missouri's settlers were from Kentucky and other upper-South states such as Virginia, Tennessee, and North Carolina. These people naturally brought very similar customs and traditions with them to the "Show Me State" as were expressed as Missourians. I was a little disappointed that Burke did not point out that fact much in the work. Sure, Missouri was unique to Alabama, South Carolina, and Georgia, but not so unique from Kentucky, and other upper-South states.

I highly recommend On Slavery's Border. It will prove to be especially beneficial to those interested in learning the details and interactions of masters and slaves on household farms were slaves were few and located in rural areas.  On a scale of 1 to 5, I give On Slavery's Border a 4.75.

Friday, January 18, 2013

Reconciliation?


This image that was on the Puck magazine cover for the Memorial Day 1899 edition caught my attention. It shows a Confederate veteran on the left and Union veteran on the right with a Spanish-American War soldier in the middle serving as a bridge of reconciliation between the two sections. A United States of America flag bunting serves as a backdrop for the three men.

Maybe it shouldn't seem strange that it largely took a war to help heal the wounds caused by the Civil War and Reconstruction, but somehow it does. I suppose having to focus on a common enemy helped the country move past some old grudges; at least on a sectional level.

Naturally, some grudges remained. Racial prejudice, of course, unfortunately did not end with the demise of slavery. It took much longer for white and black Americans to begin to see themselves as equals and start healing old wounds that the "peculiar institution" had caused and prejudice perpetuated.

Courtesy of the Library of Congress.

Thursday, January 17, 2013

A Closer Look


The above photograph was taken at Aiken's Landing on the James River in Virginia during the Civil War. Like many period images it is difficult to see details without enlarging the image. However, once enlarged, the photograph seemingly takes on a new life.


The fourth individual from the left is a slave woman sitting behind a pile of rails with her hands folded on her lap. It appears that she has a ring on her left hand. Her head is wrapped and she has a determined countenance.


To the woman's left is the old and the young. The old man is wearing a double-breasted coat over what appears to be a vest and shirt. He has a stocking cap on his head.  The young man to the old man's left wears a Union army forage cap and enlisted man's four-button blouse.  It would be interesting to know if these two are related. Perhaps they are grandfather or great-grandfather and grandson.


To the young man's left is yet an even younger boy. He sits on the rails with one leg thrown over plank and rests his chin in his hand. Like the older boy, he has a Union army cap. He has his pant legs rolled up and is barefoot. It is difficult to tell what time of year it was when this photograph was taken, but judging from the bare trees it must have been fall, winter, or early spring. A barrel half sits just behind the young fellow.


A period wheelbarrow rests empty just to the right side of the pile of rails. Surely this simple implement was used many times by the plantation's slaves. 

Courtesy of the Library of Congress.

Monday, January 14, 2013

Wha'cha Know About This?


Perusing the online object catalog of the Kentucky Historical Society I found the above certificate.  As one can see, it is from the Southern Orphan Association in Richmond, Virginia, and is dated 1867.  It says it is a $1.00 denomination "in the Award of premiums for the benefit of the Widows and Orphans of the Southern States," and bears the image of Thomas Jonathan "Stonewall" Jackson. It is singed by a "Managing Director," which looks to be Thomas L. Rosser, and is numbered 11765.

Doing a quick internet search I wasn't able to find much anything on the Southern Orphan Association or Thomas Rosset. I would like to learn more about this organization; how long they lasted, how successful they were in helping the orphans of Confederate soldiers, and if there were branches in other cities or states.

One thing that I did find in searching was that former Virginia Governor Henry A. Wise was president of the Southern Widows and Orphans Aid Association in Richmond. Was Wise's organization the same as that that issued the above certificate?

In addition, recently I read an essay in the book Children and Youth during the Civil War Era titled "Reconstructing Social Obligation: White Orphan Asylums Post-Emancipation Richmond."  It covered the Richmond Female Humane Association and the Richmond Male Orphan Asylum, and even Norfolk's Jackson Orphan Asylum, but I don't remember it mentioning the Southern Orphan Association.

If you happen to know anything related to this certificate or organization, I would appreciate any insights.

Saturday, January 12, 2013

A Family Quarrel


In this reprint of a period political cartoon Uncle Sam (holding split map marked "United")and "Aunt" Confederacy (holding split map marked "States" - also note her apron) engage in an argument while an apparently enslaved man makes his escape.

Courtesy of the Library of Congress.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Miss Historic Beauty 2013


Courtesy of the Library of Congress.