Sunday, September 16, 2012

1861 Border State Conference in Frankfort

At the end of May 1861, a Border State Conference was held in Frankfort, Kentucky. It was chaired by notable politician John Jordan Crittenden (pictured), who's compromise proposal had been unable to breech the nation's division the previous winter. At the conference's conclusion the committee made addresses to the nation at large and to the people of Kentucky.

In their message to Kentucky the committee explained that the state declined to fill Lincoln's order for troops after Fort Sumter out of a spirit of the "purest patriotism," rather than comply and be guilty of further fracturing the country.  The state's action was made for "self-preservation" and was thankfully "respected by the [Lincoln] administration."

The message confirmed Kentucky's continued loyalty to the Union: "In all things she is as loyal as ever to the Constitutional administration of the Government. She will follow the Stars and Stripes to the utmost regions of the earth, and defend it from foreign insult. She refuses alliance with any who would destroy the Union."

Kentucky sought to be mediator in the country's trouble, much as political hero Henry Clay in the past had done with offering compromises. "When called to take part in it, she believes that there is more honor in the breach than in the observance of any supposed duty to perform it." To do so the commonwealth "announced her intention to refrain from aggression upon others, she must protest against her sail being made the theatre of military operations by any belligerent. The war must not be transferred, by the warring sections, from their own to her borders."

This war was serious stuff the committee reminded anyone who would listen. "The day of mere party platforms has, we trust, gone forever. It has passed from being a mere struggle for place that may gratify personal ambition, to one for the present and future welfare of a whole people, for the safety of homes and firesides."  It came down to this: "Union or no Union--Government or no Government--nationality or no nationality. Before this grand and commanding question everything else gives way."

The committee recognized that the war was unnecessary as "it so happened that at this dangerous crisis, when a sectional President had been elected, there was a majority in opposition to him in both Houses of Congress, by which he could have been controlled, and the people protected." But, unwisely, as the Southern states seceded, their representatives left Washington "and placed a President who would have been in a minority at the head of a triumphant majority."

During this mess though "Kentucky remained true to herself, contending with all her might for what were considered to to be the rights of the people, and although one after another of the [slave] States that should have been by her side ungenerously deserted her, leaving her almost along in the field, yet she did not surrender her rights under the Constitution, and never will surrender them."  And, for a point of emphasis they remarked " She will insist upon her constitutional rights in the Union, and not out of it."

Much like rejecting Lincoln's call for troops, Kentucky also refused to secede, not out of submission to the Lincoln administration, but out of "exalted patriotism." By maintaining a neutral position, Kentucky hoped to avoid being desolated by the contending armies. "Already the cannon and bayonets of another section are visible on our most exposed border. Let these hostile armies meet on our soil, and it will matter but little to us which may succeed, for destruction to us will be the inevitable result. Our fields will be laid waste, our houses and cities burned, our people will be slain, and this goodly land be baptized 'the land of blood.'" To emphasize slavery's central role in the disagreements between the belligerents and importance to the state it was added, "And, even the institution, to preserve or control which this wretched was was undertaken, will be extermination in the general ruin."

The committee warned that no matter how much danger there was from outside the state there was potential trouble in the Bluegrass State too if they citizens did not stick together. "People of Kentucky, look well to it that you do not get to fighting among yourselves, for then, indeed, you will find, that it is an ill fight where he that wins had the worst of it. Endeavor to be of one mind, and strive to keep the State steady in her present position. Hold fast to that sheet-anchor of republican liberty, that the will of the majority constitutionally and legally expressed must govern."  And "Trust and love one another. Avoid angry strife. Frown upon the petty ambition of demagogues who would stir up bad passions among you."

Kentucky, of course, would not maintain their position of neutrality throughout the war. It probably was not possible as the war escalated. Unfortunately, too, when those tough decisions were made and lines were drawn Kentuckians did not "stick together."  Some fought for the Union, some fought for the Confederacy, some fought for their own material gain and to take from their neighbors, and some simply tried as best they could to sit it out. The Civil War in Kentucky should serve as an illustrated reminder of what results when compromise breaks down and minds are closed to diplomacy.

Image courtesy of the Library of Congress

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Researching Georgia? No History For You!

I was disappointed to learn earlier this week, that due to budget cuts, the Georgia state archives would be closed to the public and its staff would be drastically reduced. I know first-hand what it feels like to lose a public history job due to circumstances beyond one's control and the results of our nation's economy. It is sad to think that the field I have chosen as my career is too often viewed as "nonessential."

I suppose it could be worse. Fortunately, Georgia is the only state archives that has closed - so far. I have no remedy other than to let our elected officials know the importance of having public history services continued. It would be great if somehow we could get these institutions to where they sustained themselves fiscally, but that is probably not realistic in many instances. However, in my humble opinion their continuance is worth the expense in maintaining them and making them available to the public. How are we to derive knowledge from the past to make informed decisions in the present and future if we do not have ready access to primary source evidence?

Here an article on this disappointing situation from the National Coalition for History:


On September 13, Georgia Secretary of State Brian Kemp announced that due to budget cuts the Georgia State Archives would be closing on November 1. After that date, the public will only be allowed to access the building by appointment; however, the number of appointments could be limited based on the schedule of the remaining employees. Georgia will become the only state without a fully accessible state archives.
Kemp, whose office oversees the archives, said an order by Governor Nathan Deal to reduce state agency budgets by an additional 3 percent necessitated his action. The edict forced Kemp to come up with an additional $733,000 cut in his agency’s budget. Kemp refused to speculate how many of the agency’s employees would be laid off.
Kemp said he would seek to restore funding for the archives when the Georgia state legislature convenes in January. “I will fight during this legislative session to have this cut restored so the people will have a place to meet, research, and review the historical records of Georgia.”
The National Coalition for History will be working with historians, archivists and other affected stakeholders to have the decision reversed.
Official statement from the Georgia Secretary of State:
“The Governor’s Office of Planning and Budget has instructed the Office of the Secretary of State to further reduce its budget for AFY13 and FY14 by 3% ($732,626). As it has been for the past two years, these cuts do not eliminate excess in the agency, but require the agency to further reduce services to the citizens of Georgia. As an agency that returns over three times what is appropriated back to the general fund, budget cuts present very challenging decisions. We have tried to protect the services that the agency provides in support of putting people to work, starting small businesses, and providing public safety.
To meet the required cuts, it is with great remorse that I have to announce, effective November 1, 2012, the Georgia State Archives located in Morrow, GA will be closed to the public. The decision to reduce public access to the historical records of this state was not arrived at without great consternation. To my knowledge, Georgia will be the only state in the country that will not have a central location in which the public can visit to research and review the historical records of their government and state. The staff that currently works to catalog, restore, and provide reference to the state of Georgia’s permanent historical records will be reduced. The employees that will be let go through this process are assets to the state of Georgia and will be missed. After November 1st, the public will only be allowed to access the building by appointment; however, the number of appointments could be limited based on the schedule of the remaining employees.
Since FY08, the Office of the Secretary of State has been required to absorb many budget reductions, often above the minimum, while being responsible for more work. I believe that transparency and open access to records are necessary for the public to educate themselves on the issues of our government. I will fight during this legislative session to have this cut restored so the people will have a place to meet, research, and review the historical records of Georgia.”

Thursday, September 13, 2012

Just Finished Reading


I remember as a youngster how crushed I was when I found out that my native East Tennessee was largely Unionist in its sympathies.  As I have aged I have learned some of the reasons that the citizens in that part of the state chose the path they did.  I have also learned that there were Unionists in other parts of Tennessee, some of whom felt a stronger attachment to the nation and stayed Unionist throughout the war, and some that felt they ultimately owed their loyalty to the state and joined the Confederate cause.

Daniel Croft's Reluctant Confederates: Upper South Unionists in the Secession Crisis does much to explain the thinking and actions of those not only in Tennessee, but also in Virginia and North Carolina.  Crofts chose not include Arkansas because it was largely a frontier region west of the Mississippi River and it did not have a competitive party political system that allowed for proper comparisons as did the three eastern upper South states.

Crofts's book looks at different pushes toward secession in these states from Lincoln's election in November 1860 to his call for 75,000 volunteers in the wake of Fort Sumter. The first push came with the election of the "Black Republican" president.  That threat was enough to convince the Gulf states to leave the Union, but not the two tiers of state above them; the upper South states and the border states. The second move was a push back by those upper South states who at the time wanted no part of secession, but were also angered with the North and the president for threatening coercion against the seceded states. The final push came after the bombing of Fort Sumter and Lincoln's subsequent call for states to provide troops to put down the rebellion. The fight at Fort Sumter itself was not enough prompt the upper South states to leave. It took Lincoln's perceived coercive action for the straw to break the camel's back and prompt their secession.  Virginia went out first on April 17, then North Carolina on May 20, followed by Tennessee, who's June 8 referendum was largely for show as the governor had effectively already separated the state from the federal government. 

While much of this book focused on the parties and politics of these states during this time period, my favorite parts were the close looks at a number of the politicians involved and the ultimate decisions they made. Men like: Robert Hatton, a congressman from Middle Tennessee who held out until Lincoln's call and then became a Confederate officer that was ultimately killed rather early in the war; and Emerson Etheridge, a rare West Tennessee Unionist that remained loyal throughout the war; and North Carolinian John Gilmer who was actually considered for Lincoln's cabinet, but chose to go with his state to the Confederacy.  Other individuals that Crofts mentioned but that I wished he would have examined more fully are William G. Brownlow of Tennessee and John Minor Botts in Virginia.

I'll admit that Crofts lost me in a heavy flurry of statistical analysis and graphs in chapter 7, "Measuring the Unionist Insurgency." But, I enjoyed most of the rest of the book and it is well worth reading for the individuals and ideas it illuminates.  On a scale of 1 to 5, I give Reluctant Confederates: Upper South Unionists in the Secession Crisis a 4.25. 

Monday, September 10, 2012

John Brown Exhibiting His Hangman?


Northern rejoicing at the end of the Civil War often took the form of vengeful if imaginary portrayals of the execution of Confederate president Jefferson Davis. Here abolitionist martyr John Brown rises from the grave to confront Davis, although in actuality the latter had nothing to do with Brown's 1859 execution. Brown points an accusing finger at Davis, who sits imprisoned in a birdcage hanging from a gallows. Davis wears a dress and bonnet, and holds a sour apple. Below, black men and women, resembling comic minstrel figures, frolic about. Since the beginning of the war Union soldiers had sung about "hanging Jeff Davis from a sour apple tree." Davis's actual punishment was imprisonment at Fortress Monroe after his capture on May 10, 1865.

Image and interpretation courtesy of Library of Congress

Sunday, September 9, 2012

Irish for the Union


This patriotic envelope shows a three-leaf clover labeled North, Border States, and South, as all part of the in common Union.

The included poem reads:
"Here's to Ireland's SHAMROCK, may its pure unsullied green,
As a bond of love and UNION 'midst the Irish e'er be seen,
And may it help bind the love of the exiled Irish shown,
To the land which gave them liberty, a shelter and a home."

Courtesy Library of Congress

Saturday, September 8, 2012

A Slave Before and a Soldier After

In a speech on July 6, 1863, in Philadelphia, Frederick Douglass said "Once let the black man get upon his person the brass letters US, let him get an eagle on his button, and a musket on his shoulder, and bullets in his pocket, and there is no power on earth or under the earth which can deny that he has earned the right of citizenship in the United States."

That very thing is what many people, both North and South, feared with African Americans serving as soldiers. Those that opposed black enlistments saw their service as a slippery slope. Opposition thinking went along these lines: if black men were allowed to be soldiers, then they were men and worthy of citizenship. If they were citizens then they were political and social equals to whites. If they were political and social equals to whites then they could vote and serve on court juries and run for political office. If they could vote, serve on court juries and run for political office they they could potentially change the status quo of white supremacy.


The transformation from slave to soldier is no better illustrated than in two photos of Private Hubbard Pryor of Company A, 44th United States Colored Infantry. As a slave Pryor is shown in the above image with ill-fitting, torn and ragged clothing, misshapen hat and in a seated position. It is not known if the photographer had Pryor sit rather than stand for the slave image of the photograph for a specific reason, but sitting, rather than standing, infers a powerlessness.


Conversely, Pryor is depicted in the soldier image standing (as a man) in a well fitting soldier's frock coat, forage cap, soldiers' accouterments and rifle musket.

Pryor's service records state he was 22 years old, 5' 7" tall, born in Polk County, Georgia, and enlisted on March 7, 1864 in Chattanooga, Tennessee. However, Pryor's Union service appeared to be short-lived, as he was captured at Dalton, Georgia in October 1864. Pryor was probably either sent to a prisoner of war camp, or more likely he was returned to slavery. Regardless of his fate, Pryor's transformation from slave to soldier is striking and is a significant reason so many former slaves took the risk of serving.

Images courtesy of the National Archives and Records Administration.

Friday, September 7, 2012

Should We All Know Certain Things in History?

I am of the mind that the skills one learns by "doing" history (analyzing, synthesizing, interpreting, and arguing a point based on evidence) are more important than the bits of specific content knowledge that usually get measured on student tests.

HOWEVER, I do think there are certain pieces of information that every good citizen of our nation should know. I think everyone should know what year we declared our independence from Great Britain. I think everyone should know what year the Civil War started - and ended. I think everyone should know what year Pearl Harbor was bombed. I think everyone should know what year Dr. King gave his "I Have a Dream" speech, what year he was assassinated, and where. And, I think everyone should know what year slavery ended. After all, that was a major event in our nation's history, right?

Recently while watching a rerun episode of The Big Bang Theory I was disappointed to hear know-it-all character Sheldon tell his friend Leonard that slavery ended in 1863. I suppose by saying so Sheldon thought the Emancipation Proclamation (effective January 1, 1863) ended slavery, but as we know, Lincoln's edict did not end slavery. It would take the  ratification of a constitutional amendment (13th) in December 1865 to end the "peculiar institution." I don't necessarily expect Hollywood to get everything historically correct. They certainly don't in their feature film historical depictions, so why would they in other ventures.

But, I do hold our political representatives (maybe I shouldn't) more accountable for their historical knowledge. I would hope that they would be using lessons from history to make good decisions for us in the present and for our future. That is why I guess I was stunned to watch a clip from the Colbert Report that featured Yvette Clarke, a congresswoman from Brooklyn, New York. In the clip Clarke showed her limited American history content knowledge by thinking that slavery was still in effect in Brooklyn in 1898 and that the Dutch were responsible for it. And, while The Colbert Report is a comedy show, I didn't get the impression that Clarke was joking around. I would hope that anyone that took an American history survey course in college would know that slavery had ended over 30 years earlier in the United States, and much earlier in New York.

But, then again, maybe I am being a history snob. Would a chef expect everyone to know how to poach an egg? Maybe. Would a mathematician expect everyone to know how to "find x?" Maybe.

Watch for yourself:
 Yvette Clarke on Colbert Report

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

The Haitian Revolution and the 1792 Kentucky Constitution

I just came across a reference to the Haitian Revolution that I certainly was not expecting. During the 1792 Kentucky constitutional debate a stir was raised by a delegate named David Rice.

Rice was a Presbyterian minister who came to Kentucky in the early 1780s from Virginia at the behest of a group of believers on the then bluegrass frontier. Rice arrived and went to work evangelizing. He helped start the Transylvania Synod and Transylvania Seminary, which would eventually become Transylvania University.

During the proceedings of the Kentucky constitutional convention in 1792 Rice made a speech on slavery and its inconsistency "with justice and good policy."  In the speech Rice argued that slavery took away a man's free will and put it in the hands of another, which was contrary to Biblical teaching. He also warned that slavery was brewing a future cataclysmic event in America that was then being carried out elsewhere.

"It cannot be consistent with the principles of good policy to keep a numerous, a growing body of people among us, who add not strength to us in time of war; who are under the strongest temptations to join an enemy, as it is scarce possible they can lose and may be great gainers, by the event; who will count so many against us in an hours of danger and distress. A people whose interest it will be, whenever in their power, to subvert the government, and throw all into confusion. Can it be safe? Can it be good policy? Can it be in our interest or the interest of our posterity, to nourish within our own bowels such an injured, inveterate foe; a foe, with whom we must be in a state eternal war? What havock would a handful of savages [Indians], in conjunction with this domestic enemy [slaves] make in our country! Especially at a period when the main body of the inhabitants were softened by luxury and ease, and quite unfitted by the hardships and dangers of war. Let us turn our eyes to the West Indies; and there learn the melancholy effects of this wretched policy. We may there read them written with the blood of thousands. There you may see the fable, let me say, the brave sons of Africa, engaged in a noble conflict with their inveterate foes. There you may see thousands fired with a generous resentment of the greatest injuries, and bravely sacrificing their lives at the alter of liberty."

Rice's painting of the Haitian Revolution as fight for liberty, so close on its beginning heels is quite interesting. It seems that his calling the insurgents "brave sons of Africa," and their cause "a noble conflict" would be viewed as incendiary language in a slave society. But, maybe, being just a year after the start of the island revolution, for Rice, it had not yet had enough time to be spun into an atrocity, but was still something to be admired. Regardless, the Haitian Revolution was known about in Kentucky early on and was used by some to try to end slavery in the commonwealth.

Image courtesy of the Library of Congress.

To read Rice's speech go to:
Google Books

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Campton, KY 1940....in Living Color


When I drive to eastern Kentucky to work on a Teaching American History grant every few months, I drive through Wolfe County and the tiny town of Campton, Kentucky. Recently, I was surprised to find a number of photographs on the Library of Congress website that depicted a number of scenes in Campton in 1940. 

I suppose I was not so much surprised to find pictures from this area from 1940, but I was astounded to find a number of them in color. Seeing the past in color adds so much to my perception of what things were like in history. Too often, from looking at so many black-and-white photographs, I catch myself thinking in my mind's-eye that the world was black-and-white way back when. I'm glad that images such as these have survived to remind me that life was lived in color.


A street scene on court day. I love the Ale-81 sign in the center background. If you are from, or have lived in Kentucky, you probably are familiar with the soft drink.


Farmers trading horses and mules near the Wolfe County Courthouse.


These men remind me of my grandfather, especially the third man from the right. Grandpa wore overalls everywhere except to church.


Street scene in the center of town on court day.

This photograph is identified as being on "Jockey Street" near the Wolfe County courthouse. I assume that Jockey St. is a pun for the horse and mule trading that went on here rather than the actual name since it is in parentheses.

Images courtesy of Library of Congress

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

Pension Records are a Great Source of Information, Part II


In those pension records that I had ordered from the National Archives so long ago were also ones from another Union ancestor, Robert F. Boles of Overton County, Tennessee. Boles is my great great great uncle. He was the son of John and Matilda Beaty Boles. His father John was a Tennessee state legislator in the 1850s, and his mother Matilda was the sister of well known Union scout/guerrilla Tinker Dave Beaty. His younger brother George Washington Boles was one of Beaty's men.

In Robert's pension file is a report from the War Department, Adjutant General's Office in Washington D.C. and dated Sept. 23, 1883. In it there is information that is likely contained in Robert's service records, which I do not have at present. It states that he was enrolled as a private in Company D of the 2nd Tennessee Volunteer Infantry on Sept. 1, 1861 at Camp Dick Robinson, Kentucky. Since Tennessee had seceded, Unionists from the Volunteer State usually had to make it to Kentucky to enlist, even though at this time Kentucky still was officially neutral. However, a later records in the file says he enlisted on Nov. 1, 1861. A unit history I found and that has information taken from soldiers' service records corroborates the Sept. 1 date of enlistment and says he was "mustered at Camp Wildcat, 24 Oct. 1861."

This paper continues with some other interesting information. It says he was "wounded in action March 14, [18]62 and left in Tenn. (The Co. was in a skirmish March 14, 62 at Big Creek Gap, Tenn)." It also stated "Left near Cumberland Gap Tenn sick Sept 17, 62" and that "The Co. left Lexington March 25 63, and spent 9 days and nights in advancing and retreating before a rebel force not more than half our number and finally halted at Stanford, Ky." Surprisingly, it reports "Deserted at Somerset, Ky About June 30, 63 exact date not known" but follows up a line later "The charge of desertion is removed and he is honorably discharged for disability to date June 30, 63."

On a 1912 form Robert stated he was born on Independence Day, 1829 in Overton County, Tennessee and that he was discharged at Louisville on June 13, 1863. On an 1890 form he stated that he was discharged June 13, 1863 at Jamestown - not sure if he meant Tennessee or Kentucky.  The reason given that he was "unable to earn a support by manual labor by reason of....Deafness of right ear; gun shot wound of left thigh and hip and also gun shot wound of the left ankle." Apparently Robert was already a pensioner when this form was filed "on account of gun shot wound of right knee." Sounds like Robert was a bullet magnet.

On a form stamped 1889 it gave a description of Robert. Age 53, height 5'5", complexion "fare," hair "light," eyes "blue," and that at Cumberland Gap in July or August 1862 he "contracted deafness of right ear."  It also says that "at Big Creek Gap, state of Tenn about 14 Mar. 1862 received Gun shot wound of left thigh and hip and also a gun shot wound in left ankle. He gets a pension of $8 per mo. by No. 114033 for Gun shot wound of right knee. He also asks an increase on said disability." And, in addition it indicates that he was treated in "Rebel Line as a Prisner." In a long line of disclosure he said "I am the above Claimant. I was in the U.S. army. I Enlisted n the 1st day of November 1861 and I was a [?] soldier up to the date I was shot in the hip and knee in the left leg and right [?] at the Battle of Big Creek Gap in Tenn. I was a member of Company D 2nd Tenn Reg. Vol." The rest is difficult to read but I can make out "they were Georgians."

There are a number of other affidavits and forms that are difficult to read due to bad spelling and handwriting. One of the last form though was from November 12, 1902 and the information was provided by Robert's son S.G. Boles who was 26 at the time. It stated that the pensioner, Robert had been married 3 times, all said wives were dead.  Robert was married to Oena [sp] Worley who died in 1873, Patsey Reagan, who died in 1886, and Suzie Owens, who died in 1909. Apparently Robert and his last wife Suzie were divorced.

There is some conflicting information in the files, especially with dates, but apparently that did not keep Robert from collecting his pension and may have resulted from information that amended to the form later by the record keepers.

These records provide a deeper look into the life and service of these soldiers than their basic soldier records provide. Thank goodness they have been preserved and are accessible so we can learn about our ancestors experiences from them.
 

Monday, August 27, 2012

Was Lincoln just Joking?.....Not sure.

Elizabethtown, Kentucky resident Samuel Haycraft wrote to Abraham Lincoln several times in the spring, summer, and fall of 1860 gathering some information and eventually suggesting that Lincoln might enjoy coming back to visit his boyhood home area. Lincoln apparently responded each time, affirming when information was correct and correcting when Haycraft was in  error, particularly in regard to his genealogy.

On June 4, Lincoln wrote back in repsonse to Haycraft's May 31 letter. In it Lincoln wrote, "You suggest that a visit to the place of my nativity might be pleasant to me. Indeed it would. But would it be safe? Would not the people Lynch me?"

On August 19, Haycraft wrote back to Lincoln, explaining that he had no knowledge of the statement made by a reporter in a recent edition of the New York Herald suggesting that Lincoln had been asked to come to Kentucky but had refused on account that he suspected a trap to do him violence. Haycraft said he had not invited Lincoln only suggested he might find it pleasant. He explained that he took Lincoln's lynching statement in jest and as a "little playfulness."  He said that he was going to write back and return the joke by saying that indeed Lincoln would be assaulted, although not with violence, but rather with potential office seekers if and when Lincoln became president - as Lincoln had received the Republican Party nomination in mid-May 1860. Haycraft went on to say that he didn't think Lincoln would make the trip to Kentucky, but if the politician did, Haycraft would like to visit with him.

Lincoln wrote to George Fogg on Aug. 16, 1860, three days before Haycraft wrote and explained that a New York Herald correspondent must have picked up the story from Lincoln himself as the presidential nominee had mentioned his response to Haycraft in conversations, but always in jest, or "playfully," as he put it. In this letter Lincoln asks Fogg to try to get the Herald correspondent to correct the story and even gave written copy to Fogg for the potential correction. The copy read "We have such assurance as satisfies us that our correspondent writing from Springfield, Ills, under date Aug. 8---was mistaken in representing Mr. Lincoln as expressing a suspicion of a design to inveigle him into Kentucky for the purpose of doing him violence. Mr. Lincoln neither entertains, nor  has intended to express any such suspicion." Lincoln asked Fogg that "In no event, let my name be used publicly."

Was Lincoln sincere in making the lynch statement as a joke? Possibly. But, for it to be a joke, surely there must there be some truth, or at least understanding, that Kentuckians did not appreciate Lincoln's politics so much that they might do violence to him if he entered their state? Was Lincoln only trying to do some nineteenth century political backpeddling as our current political leaders are so apt to do today when they gaff? It seems like it to me, but then again maybe I just don't get nineteenth century humor.

Image courtesy Library of Congress.

Sunday, August 26, 2012

Just Finished Reading

Lately I have been studying quite a bit about slave insurrections, both those that were only conspiracies and those that were realized. Many of these incidences are very well known such as Nat Turner's actual rebellion, and Gabriel's and Denmark Vesey's planned insurrections. Others have not been as well remembered, such as the 1811 Louisiana incident and the Patrick Doyle led rebellion in Kentucky in 1848. And, while the potential for insurrections never seemed far from the surface, relatively few actually happened from 1619 to 1865. Far more common were everyday means that slaves used to cope with being bound to the institution. Some slaves displayed a level of control over their lives by sabotaging work by feinting sickness, breaking tools, or misusing farm animals. Some slaves were less subtle and gave vent to their frustrations through verbal or physical gestures of insolence.

William E. Wiethoff explores this idea of slave impudence in his book The Insolent Slave. The author sorts the idea of slave insolence into four categories: the legislative perspective, the business perspective, the social perspective, and the moral perspective. In each of these classes Wiethoff provides a case study to provide illustration.

For the legislative perspective, as one might imagine, the author looks at "statutory regulations" against slave insolence. As Wiethoff states "Not only did statutory definitions of who might be punished for insolence vary widely, measures also varied for immunizing whites against civil suits after they had assaulted or killed insolent slaves." As a case study, William Byrd II (1674-1744), who was both large slave owner and member of the Virginia House of Burgesses, showed that he believed in an ordered and consistent society and laws were necessary to maintain that ideal. However, Byrd's own indiscretions with his female workers and abuses on slaves for petty infractions made that ideal order difficult to sustain.

The business perspective, too, required vigilance against slave insolence. In order to run a profitable business, especially a plantation or other slave-labor enterprise, order had to be maintained and production focused. But, problems often occurred when drivers and overseers were employed, as slaves' insolence toward these figures were deemed as significant as if directed toward the master, but the slaves did not always see it that way. The case study employed for the business perspective was a look at the string of overseers that handled the plantations of absentee owner and politician James K. Polk.

The social perspective and moral perspective are covered last. Social norms were difficult for slaves to manage. Many simply practiced a silent smiling countenance when in the company of whites and then cursed them when out of ear-shot. The case study Weithoff employs for the social perspective is Fanny Kemble, the famous English actress who married Piece Butler and lived on his Georgia plantation four months. Kemble often empathized with Butler's slaves, hearing their complaints, something most native whites were certainly not used to. The moral perspective was important with slaveholders in that it provided a Biblical justification for keeping slave insolence at a minimum. Judge Henry Lumpkin of Georgia is that perspective's case study. Lumpkin exemplified the patriarch ideal. He believed in a "divinely ordained relationship" between masters and slaves, in which slaves were commanded by providence to obey their earthly masters. He, like many masters, believed that "Slave insolence was a moral problem not because masters should be loved but because they must be revered."

Wiethoff's The Insolent Slave has many positives. The array of primary sources he incorporates for the book is clearly impressive. However, in several places he used Mattie Griffith Browne's Autobiography of a Female Slave, published in 1857, to provide support. This would be appropriate if Browne had actually been a slave and her book had not been a fictional account. Apparently Wiethoff took Browne's book at face value because, in the index it lists Browne's name and in parentheses is "former slave." Notwithstanding this error, I still enjoyed The Insolent Slave and found it quite informative. On a scale of 1 to 5, I give it a 4.25. 

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Explore Kentucky...It's on your Smart Phone...It's Online


On August 16, the Kentucky Historical Society launched a new educational technology that is accessible through a smart phone via a free application or online via a website. This exciting learning tool is currently posting information on Civil War sites within the Bluegrass State. New sites are being added all the time. In the near future sites around the commonwealth associated with the War of 1812 will also be added.

Check it out for yourself - explorekyhistory.ky.gov


Here is what a recent news story by Cheryl Truman in the Lexington Herald Leader said about ExploreKYHistory:

Next time you're idly playing with your smartphone, you have something more enlightening to do than fret about your angry birds.
The Kentucky Historical Society is launching a free app Thursday that will show you historical points of interests and bits of information on the Civil War. The War of 1812 is next up to be added to the app, and after that the possibilities are as endless as history.
I test-drove the site last week. Picking a pin in the north of downtown Lexington, I found a historical marker for Dr. Robert Peter, whose daughter, Frances, "was a unique chronicler of Civil War Lexington (and) describes life on the Kentucky home front ... (and) records military news with a compelling perspective."
A bit to the southwest, clicking a pin leads you to Perryville's Henry P. Bottom, a farmer and justice of the peace "whose home was caught in the crossfire of Kentucky's largest battle."
"After the fight, Bottom's house became a field hospital. According to one eyewitness, a pile of amputated arms and legs, 'some with shoes on, others with socks,' stood 'four or five feet high' in one corner of the yard."
A click on a Frankfort pin yields a recounting of the installation of Richards Hawes as Kentucky's second Confederate governor at the Old State Capitol in Frankfort in 1862.
By this point I was hooked and started clicking pins all over the state. This is so much better than Angry Birds or Talking Tom Cat.
If you don't have a smartphone, you can get much the same experience at Explorekyhistory.ky.gov.
"We think this is going to be a great way to do a walking tour of Louisville, a walking tour of Lexington," said Sally Warfield, digital media specialist at the Thomas D. Clark Center for Kentucky History in Frankfort. "It's using a very simple platform that's very intuitive. You touch a pin, and up comes the story. You start seeing that all these things tie together."
Some other Kentucky apps include Travel KY from Kentucky Monthly magazine and Lexwalk from the Lexington Convention and Visitors Bureau. Both are free.
From the Travel KY app I found an Abraham Lincoln-related walking tour of Lexington starting at the Lexington Public Library and Phoenix Park.
Tours are available for other areas of the state, including Eastern Kentucky, Northern Kentucky and south-central Kentucky.
LexWalk's tour starts at Triangle Park and includes stops at the Mary Todd Lincoln House and Christ Church Cathedral. It also includes audio and video.
"There are so many stories that have appeal to the commonwealth," said Warfield of the Kentucky History Museum.
And the future is limited only by the scope of Kentucky history.
Said Warfield: "We already have our Civil Rights oral history program that is online and live, and we can easily do that.".

Read more here: http://www.kentucky.com/2012/08/12/2296853/uncommonwealth-you-can-learn-a.html#storylink=cpy


 

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Just Finished Reading

What's better than reading history about your local community? Well, the only thing I can of is reading history about your local community that has largely been forgotten because it has been removed. That is the story that author Douglas A. Boyd tells well in Crawfish Bottom: Recovering a Lost Kentucky Community.

If you visit Frankfort today there in not much of anything left of Crawfish Bottom, aka Crawdad Bottom, aka Craw, aka The Craw, aka The Bottom; Frankfort's most notorious neighborhood from after the Civil War until it was wiped away by urban renewal in the late 1960s. Where there used to be streets, houses, bars, businesses, civic clubs, brothels, and community, there is now a concrete high-rise tower, a concrete plaza and parking garage, a hotel, a civic center name for the man who spearheaded the renewal, and a federal building. Now long gone is the crime and poor housing, and flooding, but along with all of those undesirable things also went many of the relationships and the sense of community that bonded this close knit neighborhood together.

Craw started in the years after the Civil War when Kentucky African Americans newly freed from slavery began to flock to urban centers in search of economic opportunity, solidarity, and group protection. But, not only former slaves lived in Craw, poor whites that couldn't afford better locations in town also called the flood prone area home. Added to this integrated mix were the families of those incarcerated in the Kentucky state penitentiary, which was only a few blocks away. Many men when released stayed in Frankfort and made Craw their home too.

To frame his book Boyd used a plethora of oral history accounts that were conducted by Jim Wallace in the 1990s for a graduate history project. To supplement these oral histories Boyd also used numerous newspaper accounts, police records, and photographic evidence, but it is the oral histories that stand out.

It was interesting to read different people give diverse stories and differing accounts of their experience in Craw. When asked for what they remembered as the boundaries of the neighborhood some agreed with each other, but others didn't. When asked about violence in Craw, some interviewees said they didn't remember it being a dangerous places, but others declared that it often was. What the people seemed to remember the most though were, in fact, the people and places that made it a unique community. They remembered Underwood-Mayo school, the neighborhood segregated school and the care and attention the teachers provided. They remembered the Tiger Inn Cafe and the good times shared there with the owner. They remembered the white Ida Howard, who ran a brothel, but was a cherished member of the neighborhood because of her kindness. They remembered African American James 'Squeezer" Brown, a WWI veteran, and how he played the guitar and banjo and gave away any extra money he had to neighborhood kids in the form of candy and treats. And, they remembered the temperamental John Fallis, "The King of Craw," who had a shootout with the city police in 1921. Sadly, many of the relationships formed in Craw went away when the buildings were leveled.

This book was a real page turner for me. I only wish Crawfish Bottom would have explored more the years of the Civil Rights Movement - the years when urban renewal was changing an already mixed neighborhood. I would have liked to have read more about the politics involved in erasing this community and replacing it with a modern concrete monstrosity.

I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in local history, oral history and community stories. On a scale of 1 to 5, I give Crawfish Bottom a 4.75.

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Just Finished Reading

I've gotten a little behind on my posting of books recently read. I suppose that I should either slow down my reading of pick up my posting. I had ordered this book used on Amazon.com where the seller listed it as "like new." However, when it arrived with a torn dust jacket and cracked binding I sent it right back and demanded a refund. Then, last week while browsing at my local library I spotted it in the stacks and checked it out.

American Uprising: The Untold Story of America's Largest Slave Revolt by Daniel Rasmussen, a recent graduate from Harvard University, tell the story of a slave insurrection that happened in Louisiana in January 1811. The slaves involved, many of which had been originally imported directly from Africa or the Caribbean islands, worked mainly in the sugar cane industry that was just emerging in Louisiana. And, although sugar planting was somewhat an infant industry, it had already gained a bad reputation for using up slaves. The estimated figure of those involved in this rebellion were between 200 and 500. To me, that range is quite large, but as Rasmussen freely admits, primary sources on this incident are few and far between, as those that investigated the insurrection deliberately attempted to cover up the incident.

The slaves, certainly inspired by the recent Haitian Revolution, were organized by a mulatto driver on a sugar plantation named Charles Deslondes. Through "grapevine" networks and allowed travel to nearby plantations, Deslondes was able to muster a large number of other slaves and yet keep the plan secret. The slaves' strategy was to make the march to New Orleans, about 40 miles distant, in force and capture the Crescent City or die in the attempt.

Deslondes and his chief lieutenants were highly organized, surprisingly well armed, and understood their goals. However, they botched their first attack. Deslondes's master, Manuel Andrey was awakened on the morning of January 8 when the attack came to his room. Andrey was able to escape although he received a number of cuts from the slaves' knives as he sped through them and out of the house and into the swamps. His son Gilbert was not so fortunate. The younger Andrey was hacked to pieces. Manuel Andrey eventually made his way across the Mississippi River to a neighbor's plantation and reported the attack, sounding the alarm.

The white deaths from this insurrection appear to be much less than the 50-60 killed in Nat Turner's 1831 Virginia rebellion. The Louisiana slaves appeared to be more focused on getting to New Orleans than murdering whites; although a number of plantation houses and building were burned along the way. But, the slaves did not make it to the city. A combined force of banded planters that Andrey had brought from the other side of the river and U.S. military forces rallied rather quickly in spite of that era's limited communication ability. In the short battle that occurred the outnumbered but better armed planters and troops quickly defeated the slave rebels killing many of the bondmen in the process and capturing even more. Some slaves fled into the swamps and were later killed or captured. The leader, Delondes, briefly escaped, but dogs were set on him and he was quickly caught and dragged to the scene of the battle where he was tortured, shot, and then burned.

A number of the captured, especially leaders such as Kook and Quamana, (Deslondes lieutenants) were tried, convicted, executed, and had their severed heads places on poles for the slaves to see the power of their masters and for whites to recognize their mastery over their believed inferior slaves.

American Uprising brings to light a little known story and another example of American slaves' unwillingness to held from freedom. It shows the importance of the Haitian Revolution as source of inspiration to slaves on the mainland and was a precursor to those slaves from Louisiana that fought for their freedom in the Civil War 50 years later. The Pelican State would end up providing more black Union soldier to the army than other state. I also appreciated that Rasmussen at the end of the book showed recent relevance to the event by linking the militant North Carolinian Robert Williams, Civil Rights era promoter of armed self-defense, to the long tradition of African Americans and their quest for freedom and equality.

On a scale of 1 to 5, I give American Uprising a 4.25.
 

Sunday, August 19, 2012

Just Finished Reading

When I began my fascination with the Civil War many, many years ago, one of the personalities that I couldn't get enough of was Stonewall Jackson. The stories that I read about his eccentric peculiarities led to an air of enigma that drove my curiosity to find out everything I could about the Confederate legend.

Year later, when I applied for a summer fellowship at the Stonewall Jackson House, I did so partly for pragmatic reasons - it paid - but I also did so because my fascination with "Old Jack" continued, and still continues, to intrigue me.

Wallace Hettle's Inventing Stonewall Jackson: A Civil War Hero in History and Memory did much to explain how we have come to know what we know about what was arguably the Confederacy's biggest hero at the time of his death. Hettle contends that early biographers of Jackson took much from their own personal stories and added many of their own personal values to tell Stonewall's tale. Subsequent authors, on into the present, have added further layers to the enigmatic man, many not based in any historic primary sources, but yet have continued to complicate a full understanding of the man.

Hettle focuses his study on a handful of both fiction and non-fiction authors that have wrote about Jackson since his death in 1863. Robert Lewis Dabney, a Presbyterian minister and one-time member of Jackson's war-time staff, was one of the earliest biographers. Hettle states that Dabney's book, The Life and Campaigns of Gen. T. J. (Stonewall) Jackson, published in 1866, was "an admixture of modernity and and proslavery moralism [and] would not only secure its influence on subsequent historiography, it would underscore the complex and ambiguous nature of southern conservatism in an age of social transformation."

Pre-war author and member of J.E.B. Stuart's cavalry, John Esten Cook, provided a romantic depiction of Jackson in his books on the man. "The writer's focus on a great general fit neatly with his romantic appreciation of the enduring ideas of individual genius and democratic ideals." Cook's works influenced many of the biographers that followed to show that Jackson was a man that all American's - both North and South - could find admirable in the post-war U.S."

Other authors such as Jackson's own wife, Mary Anna Morrison Jackson, also get a look. Mary Anna provided a domestic look at Jackson in her book, Life and Letters of General Thomas J. Jackson, published in 1892. Ms. Jackson sought to limit depictions of her husband as a religious fanatic and promoted the idea that he was a loving and devoted family man. Hettle writes "By domesticating Jackson, she helped produce a usable past not only for white southerners in the Jim Crow era but for many Americans today."

Various soldier memoirs, southern novelist and suffrage advocate Mary Johnston, twentieth century literary critic Allen Tate, and even Jeff Shaara's novel Gods and Generals and the movie it produced, are covered by Hettle. In his conclusion, Hettle warns us that a "True understanding of Jackson cannot come through the kind of great-man history that mars too many accounts of famous warriors," rather, "To understand the Civil War, or any conflict, historians must paint on a big canvas that includes not just soldiers and civilians but also the vagaries of history and memory."

I enjoyed reading Inventing Stonewall Jackson and the perspective that Hettle provides. However, I was disappointed to see that the Stonewall Jackson House and its director Ms. Michael Lynn were not mentioned in his acknowledgements. I assume since they were not mentioned that Hettle did not visit this wonderful treasure, which not only has material culture relating to Jackson and would certainly inform on how he has been remembered in history, but also has a wealth of scholarship produced over the years by graduate fellows that have now become well recognized academic historians and pubic history advocates. On a scale of 1 to 5, I give Inventing Stonewall Jackson a 4.5.

Friday, August 17, 2012

Pension Records are a Great Source of Information, Part I


Recently while looking for some old photographs I ran across some pension records that I had ordered about 12 years ago from the National Archives and forgot that I had kept. These records were on two of my Union soldier ancestors.

One of these of men, John T. Vincent (Co. D, 12th Kentucky Infantry), my great, great, great grandfather, has had me stumped.  For some time as I have not been able to locate his actual service records on microfilmed records of the regiment. But, his pension was confirmed by Congress on September 6, 1888, which is included in these records and states, "An act granting a pension to John T. Vincent. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That the Secretary of the Interior be, and he is hereby, authorized and directed to place on the pension-roll, subject to the provisions and limitations of the pension laws, the name of John T. Vincent, of Clinton County, Kentucky, late a private in Company D, Twelfth Regiment of Kentucky Volunteer Infantry."

Other information such as his date of birth and death are of course easy to find via other methods such as his grave stone and from a state death certificate (of which was included as provided by Vincent's widow in these records). Vincent was born on May 18, 1838 and died July 17, 1923 of "chronic interstitial nephritis." The included death certificate also included the names of his father and his mother's maiden name (James A. Vincent and Sarah Chancey), and although his father's place of birth was left blank, his mother was born in Virginia.

Vincent was married four times and that information is also included in the pension records. He first married Nancy Jane Reid on January 6, 1858, and she died on February 12, 1866. Next was Malinda Sidwell who he married on November 8, 1866, and she died April 12, 1901. He next married Ida Murrey who died August 2, 1916, and he finally married Mary Ballenger on  December 19, 1916, and who survived his death.

Enumerated on a 1915 form are John T. Vincent's children:
Martha Ellen, born May 27, 1860 (Living)
James Marion, born June 6, 1862 (Living)
Emery Cole, born May 10, 1864 (Dead)
Perry Jane, born February 12, 1866 (Living)
Arminda Bell, born April 17, 1869 (Living)
Albert Harlan, born May 1, 1871 (Living)
Sarah Francis, born April 29, 1874 (Living)
John Grady, born August 25, 1876 (Dead)
William Thomas, born October 23, 1867 (Dead)

One from list some Civil War information that I have been seeking. The "Declaration for Widow's Pension" filled out on January 18, 1924, says that Vincent enlisted at Albany, Kentucky on October 15, 1861 as a private. Interestingly there is nothing in the file that provides testimony from any comrades to prove his service. I can only speculate that there was proper documentation in the War Department of Vincent's service to verify his claim to a pension. I now need to go the the National Archives the next time I am in Washington D.C. and see if his service records are indeed there and were somehow just left off of the microfilmed version in error.

Image of Union veterans is courtesy of Library of Congress

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Cool Civil War Era Photograph


Married couple or sweethearts? Or, possibly brother and sister? They do look a lot alike, don't you think? There doesn't appear to be a ring on either the man or woman's left hand.

Image courtesy Library of Congress

Sunday, August 12, 2012

Just Finished Reading

The Haitian Revolution's influence on the American Civil War is finally getting the scholarly attention it deserves. Along with Edward Bartlett Rugemer's The Problem of Emancipation: The Caribbean Roots of the American Civil War, Matthew J. Clavin's Toussaint Louverture and the American Civil War: The Promise and Peril of a Second Haitian Revolution, adds a better understanding of how northerners and southerners associated the late-eighteenth century Caribbean quest for freedom with the mid-nineteenth century one in the United States.

The first "black republic" in the Western Hemisphere was the result of a slave uprising that started in 1791 and finally ended in 1804. The results were dramatic and long-lasting. Clavin contends that the France's losing battle to regain Haiti actually prompted Napoleon to sell the Louisiana Territory to the United States, thus spreading slavery westward, which eventually brought on the war. But, similarly, and just as importantly, individuals in the North and South used competing perspectives of what happened in Saint Domingue (later Haiti) to promote their side of the debate and tear down their opponent's argument.

While northern abolitionists - before and during the Civil War - used the Haitian Revolution and its leader, Toussaint Louverture, as the promise of what would happen if the South did not end their slaveholding ways, southerners warned that the fate of the island's slaveholders would be their own if they loosed their form of social control on the bondsmen. Louverture to abolitionists was thus presented as a martyred saint that had organized and successfully led the island's slave forces against not only the French, but also English and Spanish armed forces sent to battle them. On the other hand, the former slave commander was to southern proslavery proponents a blood thristy brutal leader of murderers of women and children. Louverture would not live to see his island nation's dream completed. He was captured by the French and sent to Europe where he died in prison.

Clavin's research finds evidence upon evidence from personal letters, newspapers, public and political and religious speeches - from both African American freemen and slaves and white abolitionists and proslavery men - that these contending interpretations were used by both sides to help bring on the conflict and continue it once it started. Clavin puts it succinctly in the last sentience of the book, "While disagreeing on the legacy of the Haitian Revolution and the various lessons it taught, all agreed that in the case of the sectional war over slavery, the past was prologue."

In the text Clavin correctly brings out that John Brown was a student of Louverture methods of combat, and as the author states, "fueled Brown's faith in revolutionary black violence." This certainly fits with what I have always read about Brown's influences. But, Clavin makes a mistake in stating that "He [Brown] throughout his life followed the abolitionist papers that kept alive the memory of Louverture - in his childhood, his father subscribed to William Lloyd Garrison's Liberator." Clavin is right on the first point that Brown kept up with the abolitionist papers, but incorrect on the last part because the Liberator was not published until 1831 - Brown was born in 1800, so in 1831, he would have been well into manhood and far from childhood.

The origins of America's greatest tragedy include events outside of  our own borders. Reading books such as Toussaint Louverture and the American Civil War are important to give us a fuller understanding on these external contributing factors. I highly recommend it. On a scale from 1 to 5, I give it a 4.75.

Thursday, August 9, 2012

Just Finished Reading

Several months back I read Professor Anne E. Marshall's excellent article, "The 1906 Uncle Tom's Cabin Law and the Politics of Race and Memory in Early-Twentieth-Century Kentucky" in an edition of the Journal of the Civil War Era, so I had an idea that the impact of Harriet Beecher Stowe's book went well past the 1850s, the Civil War and Reconstruction. But, I guess I didn't realize how popular this book, and later theatrical presentations, were and continued to be for such a long time. It spurred a merchandising spree and even came to the big screen in the silent film era.

David S. Reynolds', Mightier Than The Sword: Uncle Tom's Cabin and the Battle for America, revealed to me some of Stowe's biography; something I knew little about. Her Calvinist upbringing certainly influenced her writing, but not so much as to ruin a good story of self-sacrifice, love for others, or the effect one can have on others that they meet in life. Stowe, too, was influenced by spiritualism. Both she, and her husband Calvin, believed in communicating with the dead - an emerging and popular practice in the era - and according to Stowe, guided or inspired her in writing the epic novel.

Reynolds highlights how well Stowe covered her bases in her writing. She seemingly included something for everyone in Uncle Tom's Cabin and thought out her characters well to combat a great deal of the criticism that the book did eventually receive. Much of the book was set in Kentucky - mythicly thought to be then and many years thereafter to be a region of the mildest form of slavery - with kind masters like the Shelbys. But, it too included the terribly sadistic, Simon Legree, a northerner moved South turned slave owner. It covered, somewhat covertly, the sexual exploitation that many female slaves experienced at the hands of their masters through the character of Cassie. And, it showed through characters like Eliza and George Harris that slaves would take desperate measures in the fight for their freedom.

Despite all of Stowe's proactive plot line and character development efforts, the novel was, not surprisingly, maligned by the slave states during the antebellum era, the Civil War, Reconstruction and well into the Jim Crow years. Reynolds contends that the backlash from Uncle Tom's Cabin's continuing popularity produced such works as Thomas Dixon's The Clansman, which in turn inspired D.W. Griffith's epic silent film Birth of a Nation. In the antebellum years it brought forth a whole string of proslavery counter novels such as Aunt Phillis's Cabin, The Lofty and the Lowly, and Uncle Robin in His Cabin in Virginia and Tom in His One in Boston.

Stowe borrowed from many books, current events and first-hand experiences to create her story and characters. Period slave narratives from men such as Josiah Henson, Lewis Clarke and others helped shape Uncle Tom. And, Stowe apparently received some of her information on the institution when she visited Washington,  Kentucky (Mason County) in the 1830s while she was a resident of nearby Cincinnati.

Reynolds interestingly, but briefly, discusses the history of the derogatory label, "Uncle Tom." According to his research the term was first used by Frederick Douglass in 1865 in reference to what African American soldiers were proving they were not. Reynolds explains that the term was used by Douglass and other later black leaders to "goad fellow blacks toward pride and self assertion..."

Mightier Than The Sword is a well written book. I think anyone that wants a better understanding of this extremely influential novel and its author will enjoy and benefit from reading it.  On scale of 1 to 5, I give it a 4.5.